Last autumn, an annual international clinical case competition gave out honors in all the traditional categories: internal medicine, pediatrics, and (i) surgery. But one entrant, Dr. Marcus Vance, a rural clinic physician, didn't prepare his diagnostic report solely with textbooks or hospital colleagues. He drafted it with "LogicMed," a new large language model that turns patient symptoms into comprehensive differential diagnoses.
Dr. Vance's analysis won the (ii) top trophy in the competition's open division — making it one of the first A.I.-assisted entries to win such recognition, and triggering a heated dispute among veteran physicians who accused him of taking an unfair shortcut.
(1) Dr. Vance defended his entry, stating that he had disclosed from the beginning that his report was drafted using A.I., and that he had not deceived the judges about his methods. "I have no reason to apologize," he said. "I followed every guideline."
These tools have made many young clinicians understandably anxious about their future careers, and sparked intense debates about the (iii) ethics of A.I.-assisted medicine. Dr. Vance began testing A.I. tools this year because he wanted to see how the new programs would compare with human specialists. After his win, critics wrote online, "We are watching the decline of clinical judgment (iv) unfold right before our eyes."
However, some physicians supported Dr. Vance, arguing that using A.I. was similar to using digital (v) screening software, and that human medical insight is still essential to ask the right clinical questions and verify the output. Historically, automated diagnostic tools were similarly rejected by (vi) purists who feared doctors would lose their bedside skills.
What makes the new generation of medical A.I. different, some bioethicists point out, is how it is built. Systems like LogicMed are created by searching millions of clinical records and medical images, then teaching algorithms to recognize disease patterns and correlations in those data and generate diagnostic reasoning in the same style. (2) That means that physicians who publish detailed case reports online may be helping to train their algorithmic competitors without intending to. Dr. Vance said he sympathized with doctors worried about job security, but insisted that ethics reside in the medical professionals who use the tool, not in the software itself.
設問1. 下線部(i)〜(vi)について、最も意味が近い英語表現を(A)〜(D)より1つ選びなさい。
(i) (A) operation (B) pharmacy (C) nursing (D) nutrition
(ii) (A) penalty (B) first prize (C) uniform (D) ticket
(iii) (A) profits (B) morals (C) speeds (D) Rumors
(iv) (A) hide (B) occur (C) freeze (D) repair
(v) (A) checking (B) sleeping (C) painting (D) cooking
(vi) (A) tourists (B) novelists (C) traditionalists (D) botanists
設問2. 下線部(1)を日本語に訳しなさい。
設問3. 下線部(2)が指していることを、本文の内容に沿って100字以内の日本語で説明しなさい。(なお、LogicMedの表記については、頭文字のLとして記入すること。)
設問4. 本文の内容に関する以下の文(1)〜(5)を読み、正しいものには○、間違っているものには×を記入しなさい。
(1) Dr. Vance apologized to the judges for using LogicMed in the competition.
(2) Dr. Vance wanted to know how A.I. tools would compare with human medical specialists.
(3) Some doctors defended Dr. Vance, claiming that human medical knowledge is still required to ask appropriate questions and check the results.
(4) Dr. Vance has no sympathy for clinicians who worry about losing their jobs to A.I.
(5) According to Dr. Vance, ethics belong to the human users rather than the software itself.